On a brief roadtrip to pick up my second partnersys from the airport, "Icarus" by CHRISTON came up on shuffle. My wife made a joke about the Crane Wives being on testosterone now, in reference to their own "Icarus" song as the band she was more familiar with. This sparked a rabbithole of looking up every single song titled "Icarus" currently available on spotify. The result was a 90 min playlist and this corresponding tier list.
You can listen to the playlist here. Youtube mirror may be forthcoming.
Requirements for the playlist and tierlist
Rankings obviously differed by the individual participant - where we had disagreements, I will clarify the ratings and reasoning behind them.
( Commence the Icariad )
You can listen to the playlist here. Youtube mirror may be forthcoming.
Requirements for the playlist and tierlist
- Title must be "Icarus" and only "Icarus". Songs with additional words in the title are disqualified and cannot be included in the Icariad.[1]
- Not every song was included; songs that were classified as "Singles" didn't get added mostly because I wasn't sure how to do it without accidentally just starting the song itself
- Songs are ranked on two axes. First is overall song quality, second is on the quality of reference to Icarus (Icarusity, if you will). References were judged by:
- Whether they directly said Icarus's name or not
- The degree to which they captured the story
- The effectiveness of how they utilized the metaphor
Rankings obviously differed by the individual participant - where we had disagreements, I will clarify the ratings and reasoning behind them.
( Commence the Icariad )